Egan-Jones Recommends Withhold Votes on Jack in the Box Directors Following -76% Shareholder Return
Rhea-AI Impact
(Moderate)
Rhea-AI Sentiment
(Negative)
Tags
Key Terms
total shareholder returnfinancial
Total shareholder return is the overall gain an investor gets from owning a stock, combining changes in the share price plus any cash payouts like dividends, and assuming those payouts are reinvested in more shares. Investors use it like a single score that shows the true return on their investment—similar to checking both the growth of a savings account and the interest earned—to compare how well different companies or investments perform over time.
same-store salesfinancial
Same-store sales measure the revenue generated by stores that have been open for a certain period, typically a year, comparing their sales over different time frames. It helps assess whether a business is growing due to increased customer activity at existing locations rather than new stores. For investors, this figure indicates the health and performance of a company's core operations, independent of expansion efforts.
debt service coverage ratiofinancial
Debt service coverage ratio measures how many times a company's available cash flow can pay its scheduled debt payments (interest plus principal). Think of it like checking how many months of take-home pay it would take to cover your mortgage and loan bills; a higher number means a bigger cushion against missed payments. Investors use it to gauge credit risk, the likelihood of default, and whether a company can afford dividends or new borrowing.
qsrtechnical
QSR stands for quick-service restaurant, the category of eateries focused on fast, low-cost meals such as fast-food chains and counter-serve outlets. Investors watch QSRs because their performance reflects how well a chain converts steady customer traffic into profit through pricing, speed, location and franchise economics — think of them as retail stores for food where foot traffic, consistent unit costs and repeat customers determine whether an investment grows or stalls.
NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--
Egan-Jones Proxy Services recommends that shareholders of Jack in the Box Inc. (NASDAQ: JACK)withhold votes from Chairman David Goebel and directors Guillermo Diaz, Jr., Madeleine Kleiner, Michael Murphy, James Myers, and Vivien Yeung, citing severe and sustained shareholder value destruction and continued operational deterioration.
Over the past two years, Jack in the Box has delivered a -76% total shareholder return, significantly underperforming both its peer group and the broader market. Egan-Jones believes this performance reflects persistent governance failures, weak strategic execution, and ineffective oversight during a period of declining fundamentals.
Jack in the Box’s challenges stem primarily from multi-year declines in customer traffic, which appear closely tied to a lack of consistent and focused branding. Historically positioned as a differentiated late-night and non-family-oriented QSR brand, the Company has diluted its identity in recent years. This shift has produced inconsistent messaging and a broad, unfocused menu strategy.
Compounding these issues, Jack in the Box has executed a major capital allocation failure through its Del Taco transaction. The Company acquired Del Taco in March 2022 for $585 million, citing expected synergies, but later divested the business in December 2025 for approximately $115 million, representing a substantial loss of invested capital.
In April 2025, management launched the JACK on Track strategic plan, aimed at simplifying operations, reducing leverage, and improving capital allocation. However, results have deteriorated since the plan’s introduction. Same-store sales declined to -7.4% year-over-year in Q4 FY 2025, and the Company fell short of its store closure targets, closing only 51 locations in FY 2025 despite announcing plans to close 80 to 120.
Egan-Jones also notes that Jack in the Box remains highly leveraged, with a debt service coverage ratio below one in each of the last two fiscal years.
About Egan-Jones Proxy Services
Egan-Jones Proxy Services provides independent proxy-voting analysis, recommendations, and reporting for institutional investors.
