STOCK TITAN

If You Invested in Atlantic Amer (AAME)

Life Insurance · Insurance - Life · NASDAQ
Looking for the current price? See the AAME quote & overview
$1,000 invested 1 Year Ago
$705
-29.5% total -29.8% CAGR
Bought on Jul 21, 2025 at $2.24
$1,000 invested 5 Years Ago
$406
-59.4% total -16.5% CAGR
Bought on Jul 20, 2021 at $3.89

What $1,000 or $10,000 in AAME Would Be Worth Today

Real historical value by amount invested and how long ago
If you invested 1 year ago 5 years ago 10 years ago Since Jul 21, 2015
$1,000 $705 -29% $406 -59% $372 -63% $427 -57%
$10,000 $7,054 -29% $4,062 -59% $3,718 -63% $4,270 -57%

Based on real historical closing prices through the latest market close. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Custom Calculation

Choose your own date and amount for AAME

$1,000 Investment Over Time

AAME vs S&P 500

Year-by-Year Returns

AAME annual performance
Year Start Price End Price Annual Return Cumulative
2017 $4.10 $3.40 -17.1% -17.1%
2018 $3.25 $2.41 -25.8% -41.2%
2019 $2.49 $1.97 -20.9% -52.0%
2020 $1.99 $2.06 +3.5% -49.8%
2021 $2.14 $2.45 +14.5% -40.2%
2022 $2.69 $2.34 -13.0% -42.9%
2023 $2.42 $2.45 +1.2% -40.2%
2024 $2.44 $1.54 -36.9% -62.4%
2025 $1.49 $2.83 +90.6% -31.0%
2026 $2.88 $1.58 -45.1% -61.5%

About Atlantic Amer

Life Insurance · NASDAQ

Atlantic American Corporation (NASDAQ: AAME) is an insurance holding company in the finance and insurance sector. According to the company’s public statements, it participates through its subsidiary companies in specialty markets of the life and health and property and casualty insurance industries. This positions AAME within the broader field of insurance and risk management rather than as a direct provider of third-party administration services.

The company’s principal insurance subsidiaries, as described in multiple press releases, are American Southern Insurance Company, American Safety Insurance Company, Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company, Bankers Fidelity Assurance Company and Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company. Through these entities, Atlantic American focuses on specialty insurance markets across its life, health, and property and casualty operations.

Business Segments and Specialty Focus

Atlantic American reports results by major insurance groupings that reflect its operating focus. Its property and casualty operations are conducted primarily through American Southern Insurance Company and American Safety Insurance Company. The company’s disclosures indicate that these operations include lines of business such as automobile liability, automobile physical damage and inland marine. Within these lines, premium revenue trends and loss experience are key drivers of segment performance, as highlighted in the company’s quarterly and annual results.

The life and health operations are carried out mainly through Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company, Bankers Fidelity Assurance Company and Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company. Public filings and press releases state that these operations include Medicare supplement, group accident and health, group life, and other life and health-related lines. Management commentary frequently references premium growth and loss experience in these lines as central to the company’s overall financial results.

Insurance Products and Lines of Business

Based on the company’s own descriptions and the Polygon summary, Atlantic American’s insurance activities span both life and health and property and casualty markets. In property and casualty, American Southern provides coverage that includes bodily injury and property damage liability, uninsured motorist coverage and physical damage coverage for commercial accounts. The company’s periodic financial releases also emphasize the role of automobile liability, automobile physical damage and inland marine lines in driving premium revenue and influencing loss ratios.

Within the life and health segment, Atlantic American’s operations offer a variety of life and supplemental health products, including ordinary and term life insurance, Medicare supplement insurance and other health insurance products. The company’s reported results often highlight trends in Medicare supplement and group accident and health lines, noting periods of favorable or unfavorable loss experience and the impact of rate changes or underwriting actions.

Holding Company Structure and Subsidiary Roles

Atlantic American functions as a publicly traded parent company overseeing its insurance subsidiaries. AM Best credit rating reports describe American Southern Insurance Company and American Safety Insurance Company collectively as the American Southern Group, and Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company, Bankers Fidelity Assurance Company and Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company collectively as the Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Group (BFLIG). These groupings reflect how the rating agency evaluates balance sheet strength, operating performance, business profile and enterprise risk management for the underlying insurance operations.

According to AM Best, American Southern Group is characterized as an experienced writer of specialty program business, primarily for state governments, local municipalities and other large motor pools and fleets. This underscores the group’s focus within the property and casualty market. For BFLIG, AM Best notes its continued diversification into ancillary accident and health and life products, alongside its Medicare supplement segment, and highlights its strategic role within the Atlantic American organization.

Financial Reporting and Performance Metrics

Atlantic American regularly reports its financial results through press releases and Form 8-K filings furnished to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. These disclosures include information on insurance premiums, net investment income, insurance benefits and losses incurred, commissions and underwriting expenses, and other operating costs across both life and health and property and casualty operations.

The company also presents a non-GAAP performance measure referred to as operating income (loss). As defined in its public statements, operating income (loss) is calculated as net income (loss) excluding: (i) income tax expense (benefit); (ii) realized investment gains or losses, net; and (iii) unrealized gains or losses on equity securities, net. Management states that this measure is intended to isolate what it views as the core operating results of the business, separate from items that may be subject to timing, market volatility or discretionary realization of investment gains and losses. Atlantic American emphasizes that this non-GAAP measure is supplemental to, and not a substitute for, GAAP financial information.

Credit Ratings and Capital Considerations

AM Best has affirmed Financial Strength Ratings and Long-Term Issuer Credit Ratings for Atlantic American’s key insurance subsidiaries and the parent company. The rating agency’s reports describe American Southern Group’s balance sheet strength as supported by the strongest level of risk-adjusted capitalization as measured by Best’s Capital Adequacy Ratio, along with moderate underwriting leverage and an appropriate reinsurance program. AM Best also notes that financial flexibility is aided by access to capital markets through Atlantic American.

For Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Group, AM Best assesses balance sheet strength as very strong, citing the strongest level of risk-adjusted capitalization for its insurance and investment risks. The rating commentary indicates that capital and surplus levels have been supported by capital contributions from Atlantic American and that liquidity metrics and undrawn external borrowing capacity further support the group’s financial profile. These rating discussions provide additional context on how Atlantic American’s subsidiaries are viewed by an external credit rating agency within the insurance industry.

Risk Factors and Operating Environment

Atlantic American’s press releases include cautionary statements regarding forward-looking information. The company identifies a range of factors that could affect actual results, including macroeconomic conditions, developments in the health care and insurance industries, disruption in financial markets, changes in claim frequency and severity, reinsurance availability and performance, regulatory developments, and cybersecurity risks. The company also notes the potential impact of public health emergencies, catastrophes, competitive activity, and judicial or legislative changes on its operations.

In certain disclosures, Atlantic American references an identified material weakness in internal control over financial reporting and notes that its ability to remediate this weakness is one of the risks that could influence future results. These statements are part of the company’s broader discussion of uncertainties and should be considered when evaluating AAME’s stock and financial performance.

Stock Information and Exchange Listing

Atlantic American Corporation’s common stock trades on the NASDAQ under the ticker symbol AAME. The company files periodic reports, including Forms 10-K, 10-Q and 8-K, with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, providing investors with detailed financial statements, management discussion and analysis, and updates on material events such as quarterly and annual earnings announcements.

How Atlantic American Fits Within the Insurance Sector

Within the finance and insurance sector, Atlantic American is positioned as an insurance holding company with operations spanning both life and health and property and casualty markets. Its focus on specialty program business for governmental and large fleet customers through American Southern Group, combined with Medicare supplement and ancillary health and life products through Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Group, defines its role in the insurance value chain as described in its public disclosures and AM Best rating reports.

Investors and analysts reviewing AAME typically consider trends in premium revenue across key lines such as automobile liability, inland marine, automobile physical damage, Medicare supplement, group accident and health, and group life, as well as the company’s loss experience in these areas. The interaction between underwriting results, investment income, and capital support at the subsidiary level, together with the holding company’s debt and equity structure, forms the basis for evaluating Atlantic American’s long-term financial profile based on the information the company and third-party rating agencies provide.

Market Cap
$0.0B
Current Price
$1.58
EPS
$-0.23
Revenue
$0.2B
Net Margin
-2.3%
View full AAME overview

Frequently Asked Questions

Atlantic Amer investment returns

How much would $1,000 invested in Atlantic Amer be worth today?

If you invested $1,000 in Atlantic Amer (AAME) 10 years ago on 2016-07-20, your investment would be worth $372 today, representing a -62.8% total return, growing at a compounded rate of -9.4% per year (CAGR).

Has Atlantic Amer outperformed the S&P 500?

Over the past 10 years, AAME returned -62.8% compared to +242.4% for the S&P 500, underperforming the benchmark by 305.2 percentage points.

What is Atlantic Amer's average annual return?

The compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of AAME over the past 10 years is -9.4%, growing at a compounded rate each year. Individual years vary significantly — AAME's best recent year was 2025 (+90.6%) and worst was 2026 (-45.1%).

Your Privacy is Protected

This calculator sends the symbol, date, and amount you enter to our server so we can fetch historical market data and render the result. We do not save those entries as a portfolio or account, but standard web server logs may still record the page request.

Server-Assisted No Saved Calculator Data Historical Market Data

For informational and educational purposes only — not investment advice.