STOCK TITAN

If You Invested in American Financial Group Inc (AFGE)

Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance · NYSE
Looking for the current price? See the AFGE quote & overview
$1,000 invested 1 Year Ago
$941
-5.9% total -5.9% CAGR
Bought on Jul 24, 2025 at $17.05
$1,000 invested 5 Years Ago
$584
-41.6% total -10.2% CAGR
Bought on Jul 26, 2021 at $27.48

What $1,000 or $10,000 in AFGE Would Be Worth Today

Real historical value by amount invested and how long ago
If you invested 1 year ago 5 years ago 10 years ago Since Sep 21, 2020
$1,000 $941 -6% $584 -42% $600 -40%
$10,000 $9,413 -6% $5,841 -42% $6,002 -40%

Based on real historical closing prices through the latest market close. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Custom Calculation

Choose your own date and amount for AFGE

$1,000 Investment Over Time

AFGE vs S&P 500

Year-by-Year Returns

AFGE annual performance
Year Start Price End Price Annual Return Cumulative
2020 $26.74 $27.87 +4.2% +4.2%
2021 $27.60 $26.99 -2.2% +0.9%
2022 $26.98 $18.59 -31.1% -30.5%
2023 $18.96 $19.50 +2.8% -27.1%
2024 $19.40 $17.94 -7.5% -32.9%
2025 $18.38 $16.91 -8.0% -36.8%
2026 $17.07 $16.05 -6.0% -40.0%

About American Financial Group Inc

Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance · NYSE

American Financial Group, Inc. 4.500% Subordinated Debentures due 2060 (AFGE) represent a specific class of debt securities issued by American Financial Group, Inc. The debentures carry a 4.5% interest rate and are scheduled to mature on September 15, 2060. According to American Financial Group, Inc.’s SEC filings, these debentures trade on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol AFGE and are associated with the company’s broader capital structure, which also includes other subordinated debentures and senior notes.

American Financial Group, Inc. is identified in its SEC reports as an Ohio corporation with securities registered under Section 12(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. The company’s common stock trades on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol AFG, and several series of subordinated debentures, including the 4.5% Subordinated Debentures due September 15, 2060, are listed alongside it. The sector classification provided for AFGE is Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance, indicating that these debentures are issued by an insurance-focused financial group.

Within American Financial Group, Inc.’s filings, AFGE appears alongside other long-dated subordinated debentures and senior debt securities. These documents describe how the company issues debt under indentures and supplemental indentures, and how specific series of notes and debentures, such as the 4.5% Subordinated Debentures due September 15, 2060, form part of its long-term financing. The filings reference registration statements and prospectus supplements that provide detailed terms for investors, including descriptions of debt securities and senior notes.

AFGE is therefore best understood as a long-term subordinated debt instrument of American Financial Group, Inc., linked to the company’s activities in the fire, marine and casualty insurance sector. Investors researching AFGE are typically evaluating the characteristics of this particular debenture issue—its maturity date, interest rate, and listing on the New York Stock Exchange—within the context of American Financial Group, Inc.’s overall capital structure and regulatory disclosures.

Relationship to American Financial Group, Inc.

SEC filings for American Financial Group, Inc. list AFGE together with the company’s common stock and other subordinated debentures. These filings show that American Financial Group, Inc. uses public offerings of debt securities, including subordinated debentures and senior notes, under a registration statement on Form S-3 and related indenture arrangements. The 4.5% Subordinated Debentures due September 15, 2060 are one of several series of long-term obligations referenced in these documents.

In addition to subordinated debentures such as AFGE, American Financial Group, Inc. has issued senior notes under an indenture and supplemental indentures. The company’s filings describe how purchase agreements with underwriters govern the issuance and sale of these securities in underwritten public offerings, and how the terms of each series of notes or debentures are set out in prospectus supplements and related documents incorporated by reference into Form 8-K filings.

Regulatory and Exchange Context

American Financial Group, Inc.’s SEC reports identify the company’s common stock and multiple series of subordinated debentures, including AFGE, as being listed on the New York Stock Exchange. The filings also confirm that the company is subject to the reporting requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, with periodic and current reports such as Form 8-K used to disclose material events, debt offerings, and other corporate actions.

Because AFGE is a specific series of subordinated debentures rather than common equity, investors often review it in conjunction with American Financial Group, Inc.’s broader disclosures about debt securities. The company’s filings reference sections titled “Description of Debt Securities” and “Description of Senior Notes” in registration statements and prospectus supplements, which are incorporated by reference and provide detailed contractual terms for various debt series.

Use of Capital Markets and Debt Issuance

Recent Form 8-K filings show that American Financial Group, Inc. continues to access capital markets through the issuance of senior notes and the maintenance of multiple subordinated debenture series, including AFGE. For example, the company has disclosed entering into a purchase agreement with underwriters for an underwritten public offering of senior notes, issued under an existing indenture and a supplemental indenture. These documents, together with specimen copies of the notes, are incorporated by reference as exhibits.

In addition to issuing debt, the company has reported board-approved actions relating to its common stock, such as a share repurchase program authorizing repurchases of a specified number of common shares and the declaration of a special, one-time cash dividend on common stock. While these actions directly concern the common equity, they form part of the overall financial and capital management context in which AFGE exists as a subordinated debt security.

AFGE as an Investment Instrument

According to the company’s SEC filings, AFGE is identified as “4.5% Subordinated Debentures due September 15, 2060,” listed on the New York Stock Exchange. As subordinated debentures, these securities sit below senior notes in the capital structure but above common equity. Their long-dated maturity and stated interest rate are key characteristics for investors evaluating this issue.

Investors examining AFGE typically review American Financial Group, Inc.’s public filings for information about the issuer’s financial condition, other outstanding debt, and corporate actions that may affect its capital structure. The company’s current reports on Form 8-K, together with referenced earnings releases, investor supplements, indentures, and prospectus materials, provide the primary source information for understanding AFGE within the context of the issuer’s broader financial profile.

Key Structural Features Referenced in Filings

  • Issuer: American Financial Group, Inc., an Ohio corporation identified in SEC filings by Commission File Number 1-13653 and IRS Employer Identification Number 31-1544320.
  • Security type: 4.5% Subordinated Debentures due September 15, 2060, listed on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol AFGE.
  • Sector classification: Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance, indicating that the issuer operates in the insurance sector.
  • Regulatory framework: Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, with disclosures made through forms such as Form 8-K and registration statements on Form S-3.
  • Related securities: Other subordinated debentures and senior notes issued by American Financial Group, Inc., referenced in the same SEC filings and listed on the New York Stock Exchange under different symbols.

How AFGE Appears in SEC Disclosures

AFGE is consistently listed in tables of securities registered under Section 12(b) in American Financial Group, Inc.’s Form 8-K filings. These tables group the company’s common stock and multiple series of subordinated debentures, including AFGE, and identify the New York Stock Exchange as the listing venue. The filings also reference the company’s use of registration statements and prospectus supplements to describe the terms of its debt securities, which include long-dated notes and debentures such as AFGE.

For investors and analysts, these filings provide the official, authoritative record of AFGE’s existence, basic terms, and relationship to American Financial Group, Inc.’s broader debt and equity structure. Any detailed analysis of AFGE as an investment typically begins with these SEC documents and the materials incorporated by reference within them.

Current Price
$16.05
EPS
$10.08
Revenue
$8.2B
Net Margin
10.3%
View full AFGE overview

Frequently Asked Questions

American Financial Group Inc investment returns

How much would $1,000 invested in American Financial Group Inc be worth today?

If you invested $1,000 in American Financial Group Inc (AFGE) 5 years ago on 2021-07-26, your investment would be worth $584 today, representing a -41.6% total return, growing at a compounded rate of -10.2% per year (CAGR).

Has American Financial Group Inc outperformed the S&P 500?

Comparison data requires at least 10 years of trading history. Use the calculator above to compare AFGE performance over available time periods.

What is American Financial Group Inc's average annual return?

The compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of AFGE over the past 5 years is -10.2%, growing at a compounded rate each year. Individual years vary significantly — AFGE's best recent year was 2020 (+4.2%) and worst was 2022 (-31.1%).

Your Privacy is Protected

This calculator sends the symbol, date, and amount you enter to our server so we can fetch historical market data and render the result. We do not save those entries as a portfolio or account, but standard web server logs may still record the page request.

Server-Assisted No Saved Calculator Data Historical Market Data

For informational and educational purposes only — not investment advice.